Brent Fisher

View Original

Getting Good Sleep: Morning Person or Night Owl, Which is Better?

Introduction

The age-old debate of whether it's better to be a morning person or a night owl has remained a pertinent topic in various social and professional circles. Throughout history, societal structures and individual preferences have favored one group over the other. Still, the critical question remains: Does our chronotype, or natural sleep-wake cycle, affect our overall wellbeing and productivity? Let's delve into this riveting discussion, blending personal experience with robust scientific research.

Section 1: Understanding Chronotypes

Chronotypes refer to an individual's inherent circadian rhythm – the internal clock governing sleep-wake cycles and other physiological functions. Renowned sleep researcher Dr. Till Roenneberg identifies the early riser as the "lark" and the night enthusiast as the "owl." These chronotypes, he notes in his study published in Current Biology, significantly influence our performance, mood, and overall health.

Section 2: The Science of Sleep and Performance

Multiple research studies shed light on the correlation between our chronotype and how it impacts our performance and health. One such research piece published in The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism demonstrates that late chronotypes or night owls tend to display poorer attention, slower reaction times, and lower energy levels in the morning compared to their early bird counterparts.

Conversely, an interesting study in the Journal of Biological Rhythms showed that night owls outperformed morning larks on measures of memory, processing speed, and cognitive ability in the evening hours. Thus, the 'better' chronotype may vary depending on the timing of the task at hand.

Section 3: Health Implications of Chronotypes

It's not just cognitive performance that's affected by our sleep-wake patterns. A study in Chronobiology International revealed that night owls had a 10% higher risk of all-cause mortality compared to early risers. Another research piece in Nature Communications found associations between being a night owl and a higher risk of mental health disorders, diabetes, and neurological conditions.

However, these health risks aren't a direct result of staying up late, but more likely the outcome of a societal structure that favors morning activities, leading to a condition known as 'social jetlag.'

Section 4: Night Owls in a Morning Lark World

Despite the increasing understanding of different chronotypes, societal norms tend to favor morning larks. From school times to regular office hours, society operates mainly on a morning schedule. This discordance between an individual's natural rhythm and societal demands can lead to chronic sleep deprivation and related health issues for night owls.

This situation is analogous to my own experience. As a natural night owl forced to fit into early bird routines, I experienced constant fatigue, reduced productivity, and a general sense of discontent, but that was until I myself became a morning bird.

Section 5: Embracing Your Chronotype

Recognizing and accepting your natural chronotype is the first step towards better sleep health. An individual's chronotype is largely determined by genetics, as found in research published in Nature Communications. Therefore, trying to fight your natural tendencies may not be the best approach.

Instead, aligning your schedule to match your chronotype as closely as possible can lead to improvements in sleep quality, mood, and productivity. For example, if you're a night owl, you might schedule demanding tasks for later in the day when your alertness is naturally at its peak. Conversely, if you're a morning person, capitalize on your early-morning energy for critical tasks.

Section 6: Adaptation and Flexibility

While our genetic makeup heavily influences chronotype, it's not entirely rigid. Research in the Journal of Biological Rhythms shows that lifestyle factors such as light exposure, physical activity, and diet can influence our sleep-wake cycles. Thus, if your natural chronotype drastically conflicts with your societal obligations, certain modifications can help adapt your sleep schedule.

For instance, regular exposure to morning sunlight, limiting light exposure in the evening, and maintaining consistent sleep schedules even on non-working days can help shift sleep patterns to align more closely with societal norms, a strategy I've found useful in my own life.

Conclusion

Being a morning person or a night owl doesn't automatically determine your health or productivity outcomes. Instead, recognizing your natural chronotype and working with it, rather than against it, can help optimize your sleep health and overall performance. In circumstances where your chronotype conflicts with societal norms, gentle modifications to your lifestyle can bring about beneficial shifts in your sleep schedule. Whether you're an early bird catching the worm or a night owl swooping in the moonlight, embracing your unique rhythm is the key to a healthier, more productive life.